In Plain Sight at Penguin Rep Theatre

In Plain Sight makes its world premiere at Penguin Rep Theatre in Stony Point, New York, closing out the company’s 2026 season. Blending wit, humor, family drama and emotional twists, the play brings past, present and future together as one family confronts long-held secrets and a changing world. Performances run Friday, September 25 through Sunday, October 18, 2026.

Show Details

• What: In Plain Sight, a world-premiere play about a couple preparing to marry as long-buried family secrets and past choices resurface.
• When: Friday, September 25 through Sunday, October 18, 2026
• Where: Penguin Rep Theatre, 7 Crickettown Road, Stony Point, New York. Parking is free.
• Tickets: Purchase tickets

The story centers on Elliot and Alan, a couple preparing to marry after 11 years together. But as the wedding approaches, long-buried secrets and painful choices from the past begin to resurface, forcing them to confront whether those choices are compatible with the lives they’ve built today.

Getting There

The Penguin Rep Theatre is located minutes from Bergen County. Set your GPS to 7 Cricketown Road, Stony Point, NY and take the Palisades Interstate Parkway. Parking is free.

About Penguin Rep Theatre

Founded in 1977, Penguin Rep Theatre has premiered more than 200 plays, with several transferring Off-Broadway. The New York Times called it “the gutsiest little theatre,” while Emmy-winner Edie Falco describes it as “a perfect trip out of the city.”